|
erel
Sep 29, 2005
22:59 GMT
|
all photos for this challenge taken in Newtown/Sydney... outake : (LINK)
thank you all for your response!
btw. this coca cola picture is terribly out of focus..
|
|
Sep 19, 2005 23:59 GMT |
--- End of voting --- |
|
mirel
Sep 19, 2005
17:20 GMT
|
Dear friend,
As trying to add more comments and not only my TT, I built for myself a nine points coding tool that give me the possibility to add much quicker my humble opinion. The technical point is so primitive because of my beginner low tech level. Please take this as an experiment in order to improve myself; all was done with respect.
This is not a numerical arithmetic system, but a coding one that you may find on this link kindly provided by Dan:
(LINK)
My opinion:
THEME: 4
ORIGINALITY: 3
EFFORT:4
HUMOR:3
MESSAGE:3
COMPOSITION: 3
ARTISTIC DEPTH: 3
TECHNICAL & PS: 4
EMOTIONAL IMPACT: 3
And for this Challenge only:
DESIGN AND TYPOGRAPHICAL SOLUTION: very good
Please do not add the results because as Jacques Prevert said:
'One did not learn you at school that it is mathematically impossible to add the things of different species!'
(L'Addition)
|
|
van Praag
Sep 18, 2005
23:23 GMT
|
This is how I think we should have interpreted the challenge. A good photo (we are all about photography) of an antique advertisment. Making our own advertisement is beyond the scope of our (photography) skills! So TT. for sticking to the subject and doing a great job!
|
|
Buckshot
Sep 18, 2005
19:16 GMT
|
In my tt...
|
|
johnimage
Sep 18, 2005
02:09 GMT
|
Color, sharpness, and punch are terrific. In my TT. I like the camera angle but you may have cropped a bit too much on left-side.
|
|
Levee Linda
Sep 17, 2005
23:49 GMT
|
My son should have no fatigue ever. He is a major coca cola drinker. Sharp image, but maybe from a different angle. Good luck. Linda
|
|
riprip67
Sep 16, 2005
01:23 GMT
|
Looks like somebody's been antiquing.
|
